NOW VIEWINGReception
HomeJourneyCollectionsStoriesPathsMusic RoomGamesExploreMapDebateNews
Debate & reception

CommentaryContested

Remembering Coral Gardens: reconciliation or unfinished reckoning?

One side

Reconciliation and closure

The other

An unfinished historical reckoning

What was argued

A documented debate over how Jamaica should remember the 1963 Coral Gardens incident and its place in Rastafari history: some emphasise reconciliation and the closure offered by the 2017 official apology, others argue the reckoning remains unfinished. Stated as a matter of public memory, with documented facts only and no allegation against named individuals.

The records this concerns

Coral Gardens incident (1963)RastafariLeonard Howell

Sources

Bad Friday: Rastafari After Coral Gardens (2011); Jamaica Gleaner archive

Commentary

Scripture in harmony-group reggae

One side

Devotional roots

The other

Pop afterlife

Records such as The Melodians' "Rivers of Babylon" show how biblical text, Rastafari reasoning and vocal harmony could operate as both devotional language and popular song. Later covers widened the audience while changing how some listeners understood the source context.

Read the argument →

Debate

"Legalize It": sacrament and rights, or endorsement of vice?

One side

Cannabis as Rasta sacrament and a legalization-rights cause

The other

A broadcast ban to protect public morality

Peter Tosh's 1976 'Legalize It' was banned from Jamaican radio and copies were seized by customs, on the grounds that it promoted an illegal drug. Tosh and his supporters framed ganja as a Rastafari sacrament and the ban as state suppression of a legitimate call for cannabis reform and an answer to police harassment; he responded by printing the song's lyrics as a paid newspaper advertisement and posing amid cannabis plants on the album cover. Authorities and respectability-minded critics defended the ban as protecting public morals. Grounded in Far Out Magazine's 'Ban Tosh, Radio Told' account and the Wikipedia entry on the album.

Read the argument →

Commentary

"Oh Carolina" and the respectability of Rasta drumming

One side

African/Rasta drumming as cultural affirmation

The other

As disreputable primitivism unfit for radio

When the Folkes Brothers' 1960 single 'Oh Carolina' (produced by Prince Buster) put Count Ossie's Nyabinghi-style Rasta drumming onto a commercial record and Jamaican radio, it became a flashpoint. At a time when Rastafari was criminalized and socially despised, some in the anti-Rasta music establishment and broadcasting rejected the akete drums and chanting as disreputable 'jungle' primitivism tied to the stigmatized burru/kumina lineage; others later argued the record was the first to give the Rastafari movement a measure of mainstream respectability and to bring a suppressed African-derived music into the commercial mainstream. Grounded in the Jamaica Gleaner's 'Music Diaries' column on the drama of 'Oh Carolina' and Heather Augustyn's skabook account.

Read the argument →

Commentary

Manley's 1972 bandwagon: reggae as the sufferers' voice or a politician's prop?

One side

Reggae as authentic mobilizing voice of the poor

The other

Political co-optation of Rasta and roots symbolism

Michael Manley's PNP built its 1972 campaign around reggae, adopting Delroy Wilson's 'Better Must Come' as its theme, touring a 'bandwagon' of artists including Max Romeo and the Wailers, and pairing the music with the 'Rod of Correction' Manley said he received from Haile Selassie. Observers have argued this fused reggae's voice-of-the-sufferer authenticity with a genuine political movement for the poor; others read it as co-optation — parties harvesting Rasta symbols and roots songs (Romeo's 'Let the Power Fall', Byles's 'Beat Down Babylon') for electoral advantage while leaving the ghettos' conditions unchanged. Grounded in the Zapruder World essay on reggae and the 1972 election and Jamaica Observer's 'That Manley bandwagon.'.

Read the argument →

All debate & reception →