NOW VIEWINGReception
HomeJourneyCollectionsStoriesPathsMusic RoomGamesExploreMapDebateNews
Debate & reception

DebateContested

SOJA's 2022 Best Reggae Album Grammy and the question of who owns reggae

One side

Cultural appropriation and Jamaican ownership of reggae

The other

Reggae as a borderless global genre judged on the music

“reggae and dancehall could have been more recognized because oftentimes other genres take from our culture and we do not get that rating that we deserve”

What was argued

At the 2022 Grammys, the American band SOJA won Best Reggae Album over five Jamaican nominees, reigniting a recurring argument about cultural ownership versus reggae's status as a global genre open to all. Critics called it an instance of outside acts profiting from a Black Jamaican art form while its originators go unrewarded; defenders pointed to reggae's deliberately international reach and the Academy's genre-not-nationality criteria. Nominee Spice publicly voiced the ownership grievance. The following year the award returned to a Jamaican act, Kabaka Pyramid ('The Kalling'), which some read as a corrective.

The records this concerns

SpiceKabaka PyramidGrammy Award for Best Reggae Album

Commentary

Awards are reception, not final proof

One side

Industry recognition

The other

Community influence

Awards such as Grammy, IRAWMA and JaRIA honours are useful reception evidence but should be interpreted alongside local archives, recordings, press and community memory.

Read the argument →

Debate

Dancehall Queen style: female self-fashioning vs vulgarity

One side

Revealing dancehall fashion as women's self-expression, empowerment and cultural economy

The other

Vulgarity and a corrupting moral influence

The Dancehall Queen figure and the bold 'skin-out' aesthetic — batty riders, wigs, elaborate custom outfits, exemplified by 1990s icon Carlene 'the Dancehall Queen' Smith and later by artists like Spice — anchored a recurring respectability argument. Supporters framed the fashion as female autonomy, body confidence and an economy of style and competition; critics (including church and 'uptown' commentators) condemned it as vulgar, over-sexualised and a bad influence, especially on young women.

Read the argument →

Debate

Female sexual candour in dancehall: agency or objectification?

One side

Sexual agency & answer to male slackness

The other

Reproduced objectification

Two documented readings, stated neutrally: some scholars and artists frame explicit, female-voiced lyrics as claims of sexual agency answering decades of male 'slackness'; others argue they can reproduce the same objectifying frame. Carolyn Cooper's work is often cited on the agency side.

Read the argument →

Debate

Should dancehall and reggae share one category, or does the umbrella erase dancehall?

One side

Dancehall as a distinct genre needing its own recognition

The other

A unifying reggae umbrella that maximises Jamaica's collective visibility

The Grammy Best Reggae Album category and, to critics, the UNESCO 'reggae' heritage framing both fold dancehall under a 'reggae' banner, prompting an ongoing argument in the Jamaican music press about whether dancehall deserves separate recognition. One side holds that dancehall is a distinct genre with its own economy, artists and aesthetics that gets flattened and under-rewarded when judged as 'reggae'; the other argues the shared roots and small market make a single umbrella practical and that splitting it would dilute Jamaica's collective clout. The dispute recurs each awards season and around the 2018 UNESCO inscription, which named reggae rather than dancehall.

Read the argument →

All debate & reception →