The crooner in the dancehall: singing against the deejay era
One side
Melodic 'lovers' singing as a durable counter-current
The other
Deejay toasting as dancehall's defining voice
What was argued
Documented commentary on the place of melodic singing within a deejay-dominated dancehall, stated neutrally: one view treats the 'golden-voiced' crooner tradition as a durable counter-current that kept romance and R&B in the music; another treats toasting and the deejay as dancehall's defining voice, with singers a secondary strand. Neutral framing; no verdict.
The records this concerns
Sources
Beth Lesser, Dancehall; Rough Guide to Reggae; Jamaica Gleaner archive