NOW VIEWINGStory
HomeJourneyCollectionsStoriesPathsMusic RoomGamesExploreMapDebateNews
Explore

STORY · GLOBAL

The Reggae Grammy argument

Well supported

One category, a whole family of genres, and a recurring question: who counts as reggae?

The trophy is small; the question of who it belongs to is not.
Koffee at the Bob Marley birthday celebration, 2019Pelpa Time Production · CC BY 3.0 · Source ↗
Share a memoryWrite it, say it, or send a photo.Suggest a correctionA date, a name, a spelling we got wrong.Add a source leadA flyer, tape, article or photograph.

The debate around the Grammy Best Reggae Album category - its single-slot design, Koffee's historic 2020 win, and the 2022 result that reignited questions of origin and ownership.

One slot for a family of sounds

The Recording Academy honours reggae with a single Best Reggae Album category. Supporters value the global recognition; critics note that roots, dub, fusion and dancehall all compete for one trophy, an argument revisited every awards season and logged as reception evidence.

Koffee makes history

In January 2020 Koffee won for 'Rapture' - at nineteen, the youngest winner in the category's history and the first woman to take it on her own. For many it read as a generational and gender shift, a rare moment when women in Jamaican music held the biggest global stage; others cautioned against reading one win as structural change.

Who counts as reggae

Two years later the US band SOJA won over five Jamaican nominees. Some commentators and artists argued the category should centre the music's Afro-Jamaican origins; others - including fellow nominees Etana and Gramps Morgan, and Chronixx - publicly congratulated the band and said the award honours the music regardless of nationality. The atlas records the positions, not a verdict, with Koffee's milestone and the SOJA result both part of the same long argument tracked in Billboard.

example · event · Well supportedKoffee's 2020 Grammy for Best Reggae Album

At the 62nd Grammy Awards (26 January 2020) Koffee won Best Reggae Album for the EP 'Rapture', becoming, at 19, the youngest winner in the category's history and the first woman to take it on her own — Sharon and Cedella Marley had won three times before as members of Ziggy Marley and the Melody Makers. A milestone widely read as a generational and gender shift for reggae.

argument · event · Well supportedGrammy Award for Best Reggae Album

The Grammy category the music competes for internationally. It was established for the 1985 awards as Best Reggae Recording — Black Uhuru's Anthem took the inaugural prize — and renamed Best Reggae Album from 1992. The archive keeps the distinction because several records describe 1985 wins under the later name, which is anachronistic.

argument · genre · Well supportedReggae fusion

Umbrella term for records blending reggae or dancehall with pop, R&B and hip-hop, attached to the crossover generation of the late 1990s and 2000s — Shaggy and Sean Paul its most commercially successful faces. It names a market position as much as a sound: Jamaican rhythm, international radio.

evidence · publication · Well supportedBillboard

Billboard, the United States music-industry trade publication and chart provider whose Reggae Albums chart and awards coverage are standard references for reggae and dancehall's commercial performance and for Grammy-season debate.

evidence · concept · Well supportedAwards as reception evidence

An award tells you what an industry thought was significant in a particular year, which is a real fact and a narrow one. It is evidence of reception rather than of quality, and it says as much about who was voting as about who won — useful in an archive precisely as long as it is labelled for what it is.

example · group · Well supportedSOJA (Soldiers of Jah Army)

SOJA (Soldiers of Jah Army), a reggae band formed in Arlington, Virginia, in 1997, whose album 'Beauty in the Silence' won the 2022 Grammy for Best Reggae Album over five Jamaican-nominated acts - a result that became the subject of extensive public debate.

profile · person · Well supportedKoffee

Mikayla Simpson, born in Spanish Town in 2000. "Toast" made her internationally known in 2018, and the Rapture EP won the Grammy for Best Reggae Album in 2020 — she was the youngest person and the only woman to have taken that award on her own. Her writing is bright and conscious in a way that reopened a door for young Jamaican artists abroad.

argument · concept · Well supportedWomen in Jamaican music

The place of women in Jamaican music across eras - from mento and rocksteady singers through dancehall's female deejays to a contemporary wave (Spice, Shenseea, Koffee, Jada Kingdom) leading internationally - and the recurring debate over representation, space and respect in a male-dominated industry.

Story · Well supportedRiddim and Reign: The Women Who Shaped Reggae and Dancehall

From the rocksteady queens and the first female producer to the I-Threes, the lovers-rock pioneers and the dancehall crown, women have carried Jamaican music from the studio floor to the world stage.

Story · Well supportedWho gets paid when the world streams dancehall?

Streaming globalised Jamaican music's reach - and rewired who earns from it.

Story · Well supportedIs it still reggae? A living genre argues with itself

As fusion, revival and trap reshaped the sound, the authenticity question came home.

Story · Well supportedBlack Uhuru's revolving door

One harmony group's lead-singer chair changed hands more than almost any other in reggae, and each singer carried it somewhere new.

Share this story

WhatsAppXFacebookEmail

Written and researched by The Jamaica Music Atlas music desk. The sources that informed it are credited above.

Share it freely. Quote it, teach from it, print it, put it on your own site — all we ask is that you credit The Jamaica Music Atlas music desk and link back where a link is possible, so the next reader can follow the trail to the sources. If you publish something built on this, tell us and we will link to you in return.